Bertoglios Pizza - Yelm

The service was quick and efficient. We ordered our meals to-go, but the interior was so charming that we would definitely consider dining in on our next visit. The warm breadsticks with marinara sauce were delicious—possibly the best I've ever had! All of our toppings were very tasty. Although I would have liked a thicker crust, each pizza was still great overall.

I had the best pizza last night at Miss Bertoglio’s in Eatonville! The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive.

Know they were striving for it but the ambiance doesn't feel like a pizza restaurant, almost feels like a wine cellar but even that feels off. It is so far from what I expect. The parts are also shaped like pizza slices which allow for very strange plate orientation. On the plus side, for those that care, the only people working here that I saw are women. Am guessing this is a woman owned business yet not sure, regardless its a small business which i fully support. The pizza was very good. Full of toppings and decent flavor. It did lack a certain zest, still tasted like above average pizza yet didn't stir my creative juices. Overall think they're going for a fun type of atmosphere and am quite happy came here. Very pleased! Thank you!

They food is delicious and the service is amazing! The staff are super friendly and very helpful! Kid friendly and accommodating to our needs! Will definitely be dining there again and again!

I usually love this place, but tonight I was disappointed with a burnt pizza that had hardly any cheese. I also requested light sauce, but it was overloaded. I'm not sure if I’ll return, especially since it's quite expensive for two pizzas.