Why Not Cookies Cafe - St. Thomas

I pre-ordered a 5 dozen cookie tray for a holiday celebration. They provided the option for peanut butter or no peanut butter cookies which was great. The tray had many fresh and homemade tasting cookies enjoyed by my group, including ginger, sugar, oatmeal raisin, and chocolate chip. Service was very friendly and efficient! And the cost was very reasonable. I will be back.

Great food, good prices! Perfect for lunch!Nothing fancy but great for a quick bite.

We got to Why Not Cookies Cafe right during a rush. The service was still quick and friendly and our food was great! Such a cute spot for lunch with friends.Parking: Parking on Talbot Street and in the large lot behind, on Scot Street.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options to substitute for sandwiches.

The cookies are amazing, and the coffee and hot chocolate are excellent! The staff is extremely friendly too!

I visit this restaurant once a week, and the service is outstanding. The food is amazing—it's truly one of St. Thomas's hidden gems.