American Cheese - Sayville

Knocking out Christmas shopping early (don 't hate). Stopped in for much needed refueling. And by refueling , I mean beer (and grub). Decent selection of craft: Sweetwater IPA, Moustache, Great South Bay with 2 offerings, Greenport 's Black Duck Porter and Crooked Ladder. Had the pork tenderloin and ham panini. Salty and satisfying, it 's a panini done right. Other places tend to overly toast and squash the poor sandwich so it 's this flattened, dry and crunchy mess. NOT HERE! The star today was the potato and leek soup which was buttery and smooth. Crunchy crostini, lightly buttered, proved a perfect companion. The bamboo spoons are kinda useless. They 're not deep enough for you to get much soup into and the porous nature of the thing makes it feel like it 's absorbing your delicious soup instead of delivering it to your mouth. It 's like trying to eat a soup with a tongue depressor. I picked up the bowl and sipped directly because I. Am. A. Savage. Another excellent experience at a joint with a killer and proven track record. Thanks guys!

Probably my favorite place to enjoy some nice cheeses and wines, this airy, relaxed cheese shop and eaterie in Sayville is really worth a trip. Their selection of cheeses is fantastic, and they have some nice charcuterie (the Olli wild boar salami slices are amazing, they call it meat candy for good reason). if you wish to sit down, there 's great cheese-oriented sandwiches, beautifully served cheese plates, and a small but excellent selection of wine by the glass.

Excellent little gem right near the Sayville train station. Nice selection of wine and craft beer. Homemade finger foods to die for. (Bacon wrapped dates! . Owner and staff could not be more friendly and accommodating. Reccomend!

Took my mom here for her birthday and was so happily surprised! The traditional Swiss fondue was amazing and could have easily fed 4 ppl. Will definitely be back!

This place is an adorable gem right in Sayville! The interior is very clean and has a rustic charm to it without seeming old or out of place. They have many little wares (cheese related, of course) and so many different cheeses to choose from! The sit down part of American Cheese is my favorite. The staff is attentive and very friendly they've helped give suggestions. They have a little bar area, though I've never sat there before, where you can drink some of the wines or other drinks they have to offer. The fondue is fantastic, I usually get the Traditional Swiss fondue, which is out of this world. It comes with bread, potatoes, carrots, or apples to dip in there, which are perfect compliments. If you get it for the number of people you have (two or four) it is enough to make you full, but not stuffed. I don't usually have that kind of restraint, so I usually find myself getting a panini with it. I love the Roasted Mozz panini, but they've also had specials that have been good, and the Cuban is solid as well. If you're a cheese lover or find yourself in Sayville, this place is a must try!