Fire Engine Pizza Company - Put in Bay

The bar and pizza here are absolutely fantastic! The Dill Pickle Pizza is incredibly delicious. Both the manager and Edward provided excellent service and were very polite. Definitely a 5-star experience for sure!

I paid extra for additional cheese, but received a very meager amount. When I requested them to add the extra cheese I had paid for, there was hardly any noticeable difference upon pickup, and the staff was rude. I do NOT recommend this restaurant.

The bartender was fantastic to talk to, and she made excellent drinks. I apologize for forgetting her name!

Was the only one in the restaurant and ordered a pizza and sub. I can't complain about service or the taste but when I specifically only ask for my pizza to have no onions and have the order read back to me correctly I don't know where I should get not just onions but EXCESSIVE amounts of onions. Human error is a thing. But take your time to get peoples orders right. Especially when they're the only ones at the time in the shop.

My wife and I stayed on the island for the first time with friends that have been there before. They recommended the pizza. Wow I truly have never had a pizza with so many toppings. We had it Monday night and the manager said the next day Tuesday. All the pizzas were half price. so my wife and I got another pizza to split.Thanks for the best pizza we have had. ????I’m editing this review because I just checked my credit card and the guy added a $5.00 tip to my bill.Don’t use your card here.