Athenian Greek Taverna - Commack

The food is hit or miss (sometimes it's incredibly salty), but the drinks and service are awesome.

This review is for takeout, never eaten in the restaurant or can comment on the atmosphere. Was really excited to try this place as they had a gluten free pita and a family member has celiacs. Unfortunately we were really disappointed. First off we ordered gyro and a lamb platter, an app and a salad (100$ worth of food) and we didn’t get a single tzatziki? Second the lamb kebab we specified medium rare and it was completely well done and tough. The GF pita (pictured) we were excited to try was $3.50 and was only ONE cold pita?! Not grilled or anything or attempted to be flavored in anyway. It tasted like stale body of christ from church, oh lord. The regular pita too, was also stale.Lastly the place is quite pricey at $30 a plate basically, 24$ for a gyro. Also, the spicy feta which I usually love tasted more like red pepper hummus, barely a feta taste? Just very odd.I usually give restaurants a second chance but I think we are just going to stick to our other greek usuals and buy gf bread from the grocery instead. Kind of feel like an unfortunate wasted 100$.

This was the worst food I have ever ordered. The chicken was boiled yhe pita is cheap and stale. The taste was horrible. I barely ate it. $60 worth of garbage. Don't waste your time and money they don't care what they serve or send out to customers.

WARNING the portions are gigantic!!! The flavor and freshness is everything you could ask at a Greek restaurant. We are big foodies and we can handle big portions but this place beat us! ? I highly recommend it

Low priced, Clean Lunch or Dinner Location. Good portions, friendly service and good tasting food. Have fun!