Paul Jimmy's - Broad Channel

Exceptional service. Good ol' fashioned Italian restaurant

Very mediocre, definitely overpriced. Bland food, Frank's Trattoria is a much cheaper neighborhood Italian joint and more flavorful to boot. Even the bread was bad, a notch above toasted Wonderbread. Dishes that should be delicious based on their ingredients and price. The service was nothing special, and that's probably generous. The staff we interacted with had zero personality—didn't ask how we were or if we needed more wine when we finished our glasses or anything. Wine was also very overpri … – show

Charming decor but average uninteresting food, a weird and cagey manager/owner (the guy seems afraid of people), and unfriendly (no charm) robot servers. The only good thing was the shrimp appetizer. Although everyone in my party lives in the area, we felt this place is totally out of touch with the cool friendly vibe and quality innovative menu of the restaurants in the neighborhood.

Fantastic, extremely tasty Italian food! Generous portions and plenty of seating both inside and out.

I had been on a streak of bad restaurant visits but this broke it. Absolutely fantastic pasta in a traditional white table cloth setting. The restaurant is warm and inviting, and so were the staff. Pretty extensive wine list. Menu is a little dairy focused for my taste. Pricing is fair especially for the area. Would definitely come back.